| Location | Source | Date | Page | Caption | Uniform | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1957 Topps #69 | 1957 | Roy McMillan | Reds | Head shot | ||
| 1966 Topps #421 | 1966 | Roy McMillan, shortstop | Mets | 3/4 length pose in fielding stance | ||
| The Sporting News | Aug. 23, 1975 | 9 | Roy McMillan in Front of Yogi Berra Caricature | Mets (as Mgr.) | Head shot |