| Location | Source | Date | Page | Caption | Uniform | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baseball: More Than 150 Years, David Nemec and Saul Wisnia | 1996 | 64 | The New York Giants circa 1884. | Civvies (as Mgr.) | Team | |
| Baseball: More Than 150 Years, David Nemec and Saul Wisnia | 1996 | 72 | The 1888 New York Giants (top). | Civvies (as Mgr.) | Team | |
| CLASSIC BASEBALL CARDS, Frank Slocum | 1987 | OJ-9 | Mutrie, Manager, N.Y. | Civvies | Full length pose | |
| Van Nuys, CA | Lefty Blasco Collection (from NY Clipper or Sporting Life?) | Nov. 12, 1881 | James Mutrie | Civvies (as Mgr.) | Head shot woodcut |