| Location | Source | Date | Page | Caption | Uniform | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1974 Topps #265 | 1974 | Tug McGraw | Mets | Head & shoulders | ||
| 1981 Fleer #657 | 1981 | Game Saver Tug McGraw | Phillies | Upper body pose | ||
| 1972 Topps #163 | 1972 | Tug McGraw | Mets | Upper body pose as pitcher | ||
| THE NEW YORK METS:THE FIRST QUARTER CENTURY, Donald Honig | 1986 | 50 | Tug McGraw. | Mets | Head & shoulders |